Blog

Image: No Selfies Please

13/12/2019

Marian Pallister, vice chair of Justice and Peace Scotland, reflects on a new 'selfie' phenomenon and the seemingly forgotten church teaching of Matthew 6:3-4.


How very sad that Glasgow’s night shelter had to post on social media that it wasn’t actually necessary to take a selfie when you decide to ‘help’ the homeless. The speech marks are theirs, and it speaks volumes that this extra touch of irony was added by an organisation that brims over with generosity.
 
Social media can be such a force for good – it can, for example, let people in crisis know where the night shelter van is going to be at weekends – as well as the growing aggressive force we have seen in politics and public life.
 
But to posing for a selfie of your donation to a rough sleeper (A coffee? The remains of your kebab? A woolly hat?), and posting on Twitter or Facebook surely does nothing for your own dignity and can only disrespect the recipient.
 
According to Matthew 6:3–4, Jesus said that when we give to the needy, the right hand shouldn’t know what the left hand is doing. Nor, indeed, He said, should we blow our own charitable trumpet. I think that had Instagram been around at the time, He might well have added that we shouldn’t take a selfie of ourselves giving to the needy and post it for the world to marvel at our act of charity.
 
It seems to be a sad symptom of today’s need for self-affirmation. Here is my perfect life: my perfect children in their perfect clothes; my perfect pet doing the cutest of tricks; my perfect meal in the coolest eaterie in town. And in case that doesn’t make me perfect enough, this is me handing over a doggy bag of my left-overs from that cool eaterie to someone who isn’t as perfect as me.
 
I’m being hypocritical, of course. I’ve donated, for instance, to causes on line and let them display my name. Most of us could probably tick the guilty box in allowing not just the right hand but a whole load of folk know that we are buying a ‘real gift’ from SCIAF or planting a tree in the Caledonian forest instead of giving Cousin Jim the usual scarf and gloves and our bestie a bottle of bubbly for Christmas.
 
I suppose it’s the competitiveness of ‘selfie giving’ that feels like the last straw in social media self-indulgence. Social justice seeks equality for everyone. And if we can’t make that an equality of wealth, we must surely let it be an equality of dignity, respect, and self-worth.
 
The Nativity scene was set in a stable because the Holy Family had nowhere else to go. They were soon to be refugees, fleeing from injustice. Shepherds and kings knelt at the cradle – their gifts given with respect.
 
One of Mother Teresa's favourite texts was ‘Whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me" (Matthew 25:40). I’m with the night shelter people in thinking that the selfie takers attack the dignity of a brother or sister.
 


Image: Calais Red Calais White Calais Blue

06/12/2019

This week our blog is a reflection on the refugee and migrant situation in Calais by Alex Holmes.


Calais Red. Washed red trainers tucked into the rotting tree stump, red Berbere spice, red Harissa, the hot chili pepper paste in a large tub at the food distribution – ‘but too much,’ says Yonas, ‘is bad for the stomach’.
 
Gebre shows me his cracked phone screen. “The CRS* he hit me and broke the screen. He hit my friend too, in the face.” He points to his nose. “Blood, too much blood.”
 
A red candle burns, a red sanctuary light, signifier of God’s Presence.
 
The fumes of a makeshift heater killed a young Nigerian exile. His orange tent is now a small shrine, red sanctuary light burning, a dozen small candles flickering. His photo is set into a shallow wooden box. Nearly midnight, and among the dark shapes of small tents, dying fires, dripping black trees, there’s an intense, sad silence.
 
White on red - the No Entry sign near the stadium where Eritrean Orthodox Christians meet for prayer. A wooden cross, a rosary and a small icon of the Theotokos, Mary, the God-bearer, with the Child Jesus are bound to the signpost. A tarpaulin is laid on the cold tarmac, shoes are removed, heads bared, and the young men listen attentively to the Eritrean deacon’s words. As he speaks, a white minibus parks twenty metres away. A CRS officer winds down his window and films.
 
More white. The whites of eyes veined red from exhaustion. A white full moon. Breakfast before Sunday prayers. On the fire, steam rising from a white circle of milk. The Sunday sun bleaching white the two deacons’ prayer shawls.
 
Tall poplars shedding their late season blackened leaves cloak the small encampment where we meet. After weeks of persistent rain, a lake has formed close to the camp. The half dozen tents are raised on pallets. Woldu, in his perfect white shoes, balances on a section of pallet that acts as decking to his tented home.
 
“I clean my shoes every day,” he says.
 
We go to another Eritrean camp. Semere attempts to light a fire, but the wood is wet. By burning white plastic jerry cans and dousing the wood with cooking oil, the fire comes to life and Tesfay starts preparing a meal, but the acrid fumes of burning plastic sting the eyes.
 
The flames light up the blue tarpaulins that protect sagging tents from the rain. A discarded blue camping mat floats on the large puddle beside the tents. It’s cold and damp. Birhan wears blue flip-flops. The only shoes he has – no socks.
 
Aziz, on the other side of the fire, was badly beaten three nights previously.
 
“Four white guys got out of a car. They kicked and beat me and took my phone. I’m ok. But - there are good and bad people in Eritrea too.”
 
Beside me at the fire is Fessehaye. He locates Calais on Google maps then he moves the across the Channel. “Small, small distance,” he says. He then flits across the world to Eritrea, opens his photos and there he is, in a boat on an absurdly blue sea, smiling in the bright sunshine. Blue.
 
Red, white and blue.
 
Tesfay looks up from his cooking at the passing lorries, the only means these exiles have to cross the Channel and seek asylum in the UK.
 
“Getting to UK is too hard now. It’s Mission Impossible,” he says. Somehow he manages a smile.
 
*CRS: Compagnies Républicaines de Sécurité (the French riot Police)


Image: Symbols – an exploration by Ross Ahlfeld

29/11/2019

This week in our blog, Ross Ahlfeld reflects on the symbols that are all around us and, in particular, the recent contraversy over the Pachamama at the Amazon synod.


Have you ever noticed all the ‘pagan idols’ around our oldest Scottish chapels in the Highlands and Islands? Sure, the locals call them ‘Celtic Crosses’ but we all know that they are in actual fact heathen ‘sun-wheel’ symbols, probably once used for some kind of pre-Christian worship.

If the idea of our old Gaelic parishes worshipping a solar deity sounds ridiculous, then that’s because it is.

And it is no more fanciful than the suggestion that a Pachamama fertility deity was being ‘worshiped’ by Catholics during the Amazon Synod in Rome. (Pachamamas are actually associated with the Inca people of the Andes rather than the Amazon region.)

Yet it seems that some were happy to accept this claim as reality, despite the fact that both indigenous Synod participants and Vatican officials stated that the carvings on display inside the Santa Maria were neither fertility goddesses nor objects of worship. 

The social media outrage from US conservatives hostile to Pope Francis has forced the Synod organisers to reiterate the fact that the carvings were merely symbolic of a place, a people, a culture and most importantly; a symbol of life. Indeed, some even refer to the images as Our Lady of the Amazon.

We have all seen that during the Synod, the carvings were taken from the Church and thrown in the Tiber by a young man from Vienna called Alexander Tschugguel.
I do not want to attack this gentleman but rather, try and understand what motivated this devout young Austrian to commit an act that has caused so much hurt to his own brothers and sisters in Christ.

The answer can perhaps be found in a recent interview in which Mr Tschugguel stated that he was simply upholding the First Commandment by removing a pagan idol.

Alexander Tschugguel, who wears traditional dress or ‘tracht’, went on to discuss a range of topics from the ‘globalist agenda’ to the Holy Roman Empire, to medieval castles with moats. He also considers Cardinal Brandmuller and Athanasius Schneider to be heroes, especially Archbishop Schneider whom he identifies as a 'Black Sea German'.

I sense that this is a man who deeply loves his German Catholic heritage. Yet, if the indigenous Amazonian carvings that he threw into the Tiber have nothing to do with Jesus, do any of his cultural traditions?

I say this as a fellow Catholic of German ancestry whose own parish was established by a German priest from Gelsenkirchen called Peter Hilgers who came here during Bismarck's Kulturkampf, or ‘culture struggle’ - a row between the Prussian government and the Catholic Church in the 1870s. 

We can manage to create discord between ourselves without national symbols to bring even more division among us.

So next month, when you see Wotan’s Yule springing up near the altar in your parish, spare a thought for our much maligned, indigenous faithful and their own cultural traditions. – and don’t dump the Christmas tree in the nearest river!




Page 33 of 89First   Previous   28  29  30  31  32  [33]  34  35  36  37  Next   Last